How it begins
"So you mean to accompany our party, Mr James Crichton, to the singing-class? I am very glad that you should go," said Mrs Tollemache.
Chapters 1–4Keep reading →
Summary
Spoiler-free
Hugh Crichton loves Violante Mattei, a young singer preparing to make her debut in Don Giovanni under the intimidating direction of her father. Violante responds to Hugh’s affection, but their prospects are troubled by differences in their circumstances, an apparent rival engagement, and Hugh’s doubts about his right to pursue happiness.
Full summary
Spoilers
Hugh Crichton loves Violante Mattei, a young singer preparing to make her debut in Don Giovanni under the intimidating direction of her father. Violante responds to Hugh’s affection, but their prospects are troubled by differences in their circumstances, an apparent rival engagement, and Hugh’s doubts about his right to pursue happiness.
Meanwhile, Hugh’s brother Arthur becomes engaged to Mysie with their mother’s approval. Mysie subsequently dies, leaving Arthur grief-stricken. Frederica blames Hugh, though Flossy defends him and asks for sympathy for his suffering. Hugh feels painfully responsible toward Arthur and comes to believe that seeking happiness for himself would wrong his bereaved brother.
Violante loses her voice, and her father declares that her hopes of professional success are over. She and her sister Rosa come to England to stay with their relatives, the Greys. Rosa longs for a theatrical career but puts Violante’s welfare ahead of her ambitions, which are also constrained by the cost of training. Violante later attends Miss Venning’s school. Arthur offers her kindness, while Hugh avoids seeking her out despite continuing to love her.
James Crichton’s visits and conversation bring Violante back into the family’s attention. Hugh’s jealousy and distress become difficult to conceal. He finally tells Arthur about his separation from Violante. Arthur believes Hugh judged her too hastily and insists that rejecting her love benefits nobody, particularly Violante herself. Hugh admits that he cannot be happy without her but finds it hard to accept joy while Arthur suffers.
The decisive change comes when Arthur recalls Mysie’s belief that love can bring happiness without its being deserved. Persuaded, Hugh goes to Violante at her father’s lodgings, asks forgiveness, and embraces her. She assures him that she never broke her promise to him or accepted the other engagement. Their misunderstanding is resolved, although Violante remains conscious of the difference between their circumstances after seeing Hugh’s home. Rosa questions Hugh about his intentions and his long delay in returning to her sister.
Hugh marries Violante and finds happiness with her. Arthur leaves to rebuild his life through new hopes and ambitions; his grief is not resolved by a new romance. Hugh remains devoted to him and cannot regard his own happiness as complete while Arthur has yet to find his. Mysie remains dead, and no further resolution is given for Rosa’s theatrical ambitions or for James, Flossy, Frederica, or the other family members.
The ending
Hugh and Violante reconcile after she confirms that she kept her promise and never accepted the other engagement. They marry and are happy together. Arthur leaves to rebuild his life with new hopes and ambitions, while Hugh continues to feel that his happiness is incomplete until Arthur also finds happiness.
About the book
Length
47 chapters in 6 parts
First published
Undated
Contents
Part One
Part Two
Part Three
Part Four
Part Five
Part Six
Text from Project Gutenberg.
