How it begins
“A remarkable man!” It was not my husband speaking, but some passerby. However, I looked up at George with a smile, and found him looking down at me with much the same humour.
Chapter 1: PoinsettiasKeep reading →
Summary
Spoiler-free
Edith Challoner dies suddenly in a hotel lobby from a wound near her heart. George and Laura Anderson have just seen a striking stranger leave the hotel and wash his hands in snow. The stranger, inventor Orlando Brotherson, admits corresponding with Edith but denies knowing of her death. Authorities favor suicide, citing her paper-cutter and an apparent romantic quarrel. Her father wants her name cleared, while detectives Sweetwater and Gryce doubt that the clean cutter explains the wound.
Full summary
Spoilers
Edith Challoner dies suddenly in a hotel lobby from a wound near her heart. George and Laura Anderson have just seen a striking stranger leave the hotel and wash his hands in snow. The stranger, inventor Orlando Brotherson, admits corresponding with Edith but denies knowing of her death. Authorities favor suicide, citing her paper-cutter and an apparent romantic quarrel. Her father wants her name cleared, while detectives Sweetwater and Gryce doubt that the clean cutter explains the wound.
Sweetwater connects Orlando with another mysterious death: Mrs. Spotts, a washerwoman, was fatally stabbed in a tenement opposite his room, with no weapon or apparent means of attack discovered. Orlando uses another name there, supposedly to protect his unfinished invention. With official permission and Mr. Challoner’s funding, Sweetwater moves into the building disguised as a sickly carpenter and gains access to Orlando’s work. His surveillance and attempts to provoke a revealing response fail. Orlando discovers the spying and burns Edith’s letters, insisting that their account of a romance does not match his experience with her.
Gryce discovers that two men signed themselves O. B. Edith’s true lover was Orlando’s brother, Oswald Brotherson. Sweetwater finds Oswald critically ill in Derby, Pennsylvania, under Doris Scott’s care. The doctor forbids telling him of Edith’s death until he is stronger. Doris rejects suicide and helps Mr. Challoner, who comes to Derby and becomes devoted to Oswald.
Orlando arrives to work on his flying machine in a woodland shed. He falls in love with Doris, whose presence awakens feelings and fears he has previously resisted. When Doris finally tells Oswald that Edith is dead, Orlando interrupts her account. He admits threatening Edith but claims that he later approached her to apologize and that she killed herself through misunderstanding. The news causes Oswald another dangerous illness, though he slowly recovers.
Sweetwater volunteers to help Orlando test his aircraft and accompanies him into the air. The machine succeeds despite a storm. Public acclaim, financial backing, and Doris’s approval follow, but Orlando’s growing anguish defeats his satisfaction in the achievement.
In the climax, Orlando confesses privately to Mr. Challoner that he murdered both women. He killed Mrs. Spotts to test the method he intended to use against Edith. Oswald overhears part of the confession and attacks him. Orlando overpowers his weakened brother and asks forgiveness, which Oswald cannot grant. Hinting that he means to die, Orlando leaves Oswald in Mr. Challoner’s care.
After writing letters through the night, Orlando leaves before dawn and takes off in his aircraft. Sweetwater returns with a possible explanation for the murders, learns of the confession, and discovers that Orlando has flown away but cannot land. Lightning reveals Orlando falling to his death. Oswald survives and weeps against Doris, who remains beside him. Mr. Challoner learns that Edith was murdered rather than a suicide; Sweetwater and Gryce’s suspicions are vindicated. George and Laura have already left the active investigation.
The ending
Orlando confesses to murdering Edith Challoner and Mrs. Spotts. Oswald attacks him and refuses forgiveness. After writing letters overnight, Orlando flies away in his aircraft but cannot land; lightning reveals his fatal fall. Oswald weeps against Doris, while Mr. Challoner knows the truth about his daughter’s death.
About the book
Length
42 chapters in 3 parts
First published
1911
Contents
Book I: As Seen by Two Strangers
Book II: As Seen by Detective Sweetwater
- Chapter 10: A Difference of Opinion
- Chapter 11: Alike in Essentials
- Chapter 12: Mr. Gryce Finds an Antidote for Old Age
- Chapter 13: Time, Circumstance, and a Villain’s Heart
- Chapter 14: A Concession
- Chapter 15: That’s the Question
- Chapter 16: Opposed
- Chapter 17: In Which a Book Plays a Leading Part
- Chapter 18: What Am I to Do Now
- Chapter 19: The Danger Moment
- Chapter 20: Confusion
- Chapter 21: A Change
- Chapter 22: O. B. Again
Book III: The Heart of Man
- Chapter 23: Doris
- Chapter 24: Suspense
- Chapter 25: The Oval Hut
- Chapter 26: Sweetwater Returns
- Chapter 27: The Image of Dread
- Chapter 28: I Hope Never to See That Man
- Chapter 29: Do You Know My Brother
- Chapter 30: Chaos
- Chapter 31: What Is He Making
- Chapter 32: Tell Me, Tell It All
- Chapter 33: Alone
- Chapter 34: The Hut Changes Its Name
- Chapter 35: Silence—And a Knock
- Chapter 36: The Man Within and the Man Without
- Chapter 37: His Great Hour
- Chapter 38: Night
- Chapter 39: The Avenger
- Chapter 40: Desolate
- Chapter 41: Five O’clock in the Morning
- Chapter 42: At Six
More from Mystery and detection
- A Study in ScarletDr. John Watson returns to England after wounds and fever end his army service in Afghanistan.
- Devlin the BarberAfter losing his job, the unnamed narrator becomes involved in a catastrophe affecting his friend Mr. Melladew.
- ArmadaleIt was the opening of the season of eighteen hundred and thirty-two, at the Baths of Wildbad. The evening…
- At the Sign of the SwordEdmond Valentin, a Belgian lawyer and soldier, and Aimee de Neuville love each other despite her father's opposition.
Text from Project Gutenberg.




